Under-Eye Dark Circles in Tokyo: Injections vs Surgery — Which Treatment Is Right for You?
Dark circles under the eyes are one of the most common cosmetic concerns among both men and women, and one of the most frustrating — they can persist regardless of how well you sleep or how carefully you care for your skin.
If you have been searching for a reliable, medically supervised solution in Tokyo, this guide explains your two main options: injectable treatments and surgical correction.
Below, you will find a clear comparison of both approaches, realistic expectations, approximate costs in Tokyo, and guidance on which option may suit your situation.
What you’ll learn in this article:
- The main causes of under-eye dark circles and why the cause determines the treatment
- How hyaluronic acid filler injections and surgical transconjunctival blepharoplasty each work
- A side-by-side comparison of both approaches: downtime, longevity, and suitability
- Realistic cost ranges for under-eye treatments at a Tokyo cosmetic clinic
- Who is a good candidate for each option, and common misconceptions to avoid
Have a question about this treatment?
Message us on LINE or WhatsApp — our English-speaking team usually replies the same day.
Why Dark Circles Are Not All the Same
Before comparing treatments, it is important to understand that “dark circles” is an umbrella term covering several distinct conditions. Choosing a treatment without identifying the underlying cause is one of the most common reasons patients are disappointed with their results.
The four main types
- Vascular (bluish/purple): Thin skin allows the underlying muscle and blood vessels to show through, creating a bluish or purple shadow. Common in younger patients and in people with lighter skin tones.
- Pigmentation (brown): Excess melanin in the skin itself, often related to sun exposure, post-inflammatory changes, or genetics. More common in East Asian, South Asian, and Middle Eastern skin types.
- Structural (shadow): A hollow or groove between the lower eyelid and the cheek — known as the tear trough — casts a shadow that reads as a dark circle. This is a volume and anatomy issue, not a pigment issue.
- Mixed: A combination of the above, which is very frequently encountered in clinical practice.
Injectable treatments address structural and vascular causes most effectively. Surgical intervention is most appropriate when excess fat is creating a bulge, deepening the shadow beneath it, or when structural correction is required that filler alone cannot achieve.
Option 1 — Hyaluronic Acid Filler Injections (Tear Trough Filler)
How it works
Hyaluronic acid (HA) filler is a gel-like substance that is injected beneath the skin to restore volume in the tear trough area — the groove that runs from the inner corner of the eye toward the cheek.
By lifting this hollow, the shadow that creates the appearance of a dark circle is reduced. The procedure takes approximately 15 to 30 minutes and requires no general anaesthesia.
HA filler attracts and retains water, providing a plumping effect. Because hyaluronic acid is a naturally occurring substance in the body, the risk of allergic reaction is low. Results are visible almost immediately, with some improvement in the days following as swelling subsides.
What to expect: before, during, and after
Before treatment, a detailed consultation is conducted to assess the tear trough anatomy, skin thickness, and the likely cause of the dark circles. A topical numbing cream is applied prior to injection.
The injections themselves are brief, though the area under the eye is sensitive and some mild discomfort is normal.
After treatment, minor swelling and occasional bruising may appear for three to seven days. Patients are advised to avoid strenuous exercise, alcohol, and direct sun exposure for 48 hours. Most people are able to return to work the following day, making this a relatively low-downtime option.
Longevity
HA filler in the tear trough area typically lasts between 9 and 18 months, though individual results vary. The filler can be partially or fully dissolved using an enzyme called hyaluronidase if the result is unsatisfactory or if revision is needed — an important safety consideration in a delicate area such as the under-eye.
Dr. Karibe’s Note
Many of our international patients are surprised to find that tear trough filler is not always the right first step. In consultations at BIOTOPE CLINIC, I frequently assess patients who were told they needed surgery when filler would have been sufficient — and equally, patients who had repeated filler treatments when the underlying cause was excess fat that could only be corrected surgically.
A careful assessment of what is actually causing the shadow is far more important than the treatment itself. There is no one-size-fits-all approach to the under-eye area.
Option 2 — Transconjunctival Blepharoplasty (Under-Eye Surgery)
How it works
Transconjunctival blepharoplasty is a surgical procedure designed to address excess or herniated fat pockets beneath the lower eyelid. The term “transconjunctival” means the incision is made on the inner surface of the eyelid (the conjunctiva), leaving no visible external scar. The surgeon removes or repositions the fat that is causing a bulge and the resulting shadow beneath it.
This procedure is performed under local anaesthesia (with or without sedation) and typically takes 60 to 90 minutes. It addresses the structural root cause of shadow-type dark circles in a way that is not achievable with filler alone.
What to expect: before, during, and after
Pre-operative blood work and a surgical consultation with Dr. Karibe are required before the procedure. During surgery, the patient is awake but comfortable. Some pressure and mild sensation may be felt, but the procedure should not be painful.
Downtime is more significant than with filler. Swelling and bruising around the eyes should be anticipated for one to three weeks. Most patients are able to return to desk work within five to seven days, though strenuous activity should be avoided for two to four weeks. Final results are typically assessed at three to six months, once all swelling has fully resolved.
Longevity
The results of transconjunctival blepharoplasty are long-lasting.
Because fat does not generally regenerate after removal, many patients consider this a permanent improvement, though the natural ageing process continues over time. Clinical evidence supports a high long-term satisfaction rate: one published review in the journal Aesthetic Surgery Journal reported patient satisfaction rates above 85% at long-term follow-up following lower blepharoplasty procedures.
Transconjunctival blepharoplasty is available at BIOTOPE CLINIC in Shirokanedai — feel free to ask about candidacy and what the procedure involves during a consultation with Dr. Karibe.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | HA Filler (Tear Trough) | Transconjunctival Blepharoplasty |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Hollow tear trough, volume loss, vascular shadows | Excess fat / bulging, deep structural shadow |
| Procedure time | 15–30 minutes | 60–90 minutes |
| Anaesthesia | Topical numbing cream | Local anaesthesia (sedation optional) |
| Downtime | 3–7 days (bruising/swelling) | 1–3 weeks (swelling/bruising) |
| Visible scar | None | None (internal incision) |
| Results visible | Immediately (final result: 1–2 weeks) | 3–6 months (final result) |
| Longevity | 9–18 months | Long-lasting (years) |
| Reversible | Yes (hyaluronidase) | No |
| Approximate cost at BIOTOPE CLINIC | From ¥66,000 per syringe | ¥280,000–¥428,000 |
Cost of Under-Eye Treatments in Tokyo
Hyaluronic acid filler
At BIOTOPE CLINIC, hyaluronic acid filler is priced at ¥66,000–¥88,000 per syringe. Tear trough correction typically requires one syringe, though this varies by individual anatomy. An initial consultation fee of ¥5,500 applies. If future revision or dissolution is needed, hyaluronidase is available at ¥11,000–¥22,000.
Transconjunctival blepharoplasty
Surgical correction is priced at ¥280,000–¥428,000, reflecting the complexity of the procedure and the level of surgical expertise required. Additional costs include a surgical consultation with Dr. Karibe (¥3,300), pre-operative blood work (¥11,000), and anaesthesia (¥2,200–¥77,000 depending on the type used).
These figures represent the clinic’s published price range. The final cost depends on the extent of correction required and the anaesthesia approach chosen. For an accurate quote, we recommend booking a consultation.
Have a question about this treatment?
Message us on LINE or WhatsApp — our English-speaking team usually replies the same day.
Common Misconceptions About Under-Eye Dark Circle Treatments
Misconception 1: “Filler always fixes dark circles”
Tear trough filler is highly effective for hollowing and volume loss, but it will not correct dark circles caused primarily by pigmentation (excess melanin in the skin) or by fat herniation causing a bulge. In some cases, adding filler over pre-existing fat pockets can actually worsen the appearance by increasing fullness where it is not needed. An honest assessment of the underlying cause is essential before any treatment is selected.
Misconception 2: “Surgery leaves visible scars under the eyes”
The transconjunctival approach is specifically designed to avoid external scarring. The incision is made on the inside of the eyelid, which means there is no visible mark on the skin surface. This is one of the principal advantages of this technique over traditional lower blepharoplasty, which uses an external incision. Studies suggest that the transconjunctival approach carries a lower risk of lower eyelid retraction compared with the external (subciliary) incision method — a relevant consideration when evaluating surgical risk.
Who Is a Good Candidate?
Good candidates for filler
- Patients with a visible hollow or groove in the tear trough area
- Those with thin skin making blood vessels visible beneath the surface
- Patients who prefer a non-surgical approach with minimal downtime
- Those who want a reversible, lower-commitment option before considering surgery
Good candidates for transconjunctival blepharoplasty
- Patients with visible fat pockets (“bags”) beneath the lower eyelid
- Those for whom repeated filler treatments have provided insufficient improvement
- Patients in good general health who are prepared for a surgical recovery period
- Those seeking a long-lasting structural correction rather than a temporary result
Who should exercise caution or seek medical advice first
- Patients with a history of keloid scarring (relevant for all surgical procedures)
- Those taking blood-thinning medications such as aspirin or warfarin
- Patients with dry eye syndrome, as surgery in the lower eyelid area can temporarily affect tear film stability
- Pregnant or breastfeeding women (injectable treatments are generally deferred)
- Patients whose dark circles are primarily pigmentary in origin — laser or skin-brightening treatments may be more appropriate in such cases
In Dr. Karibe’s clinical experience at BIOTOPE CLINIC, a number of patients present having already had filler at another clinic, seeking advice because results were uneven or swelling persisted. A careful pre-treatment assessment — including evaluating skin thickness, fat compartment anatomy, and skin tone — significantly reduces the likelihood of this outcome.
Where to Get Under-Eye Dark Circle Treatment in Tokyo
Within our clinic group, English-speaking consultations are handled at BIOTOPE CLINIC in Shirokanedai (Minato-ku, Tokyo) by Dr. Jun Karibe, a board-certified plastic surgeon certified by the Japan Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. Our sister clinic, Kojimachi Dermatology & Plastic Surgery Clinic in Ichigaya (Chiyoda-ku), handles Japanese-language insurance-covered dermatology and serves as the group’s main office. Bookings and enquiries in English are handled at BIOTOPE CLINIC via LINE or WhatsApp.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Q. Can I have filler and surgery at the same time?
- In most cases, a surgeon will assess which approach is appropriate before combining treatments. Occasionally, fat repositioning during surgery reduces the need for filler altogether. If filler is required alongside surgery, this is typically discussed at the surgical consultation and planned on an individual basis.
- Q. How long is the recovery after tear trough filler?
- Most patients experience mild swelling and possible bruising for three to seven days. Makeup can generally be applied after 24 hours if there are no open injection points. The final result is usually visible within one to two weeks once any initial swelling has settled.
- Q. I had filler elsewhere and I am not happy with the result. Can it be corrected?
- Yes, in many cases. Hyaluronidase (an enzyme that dissolves hyaluronic acid filler) can be used to partially or fully reverse previous filler treatments. Dr. Karibe can assess the existing result and advise on whether dissolution, additional volume, or a different approach is most appropriate. Hyaluronidase is available at BIOTOPE CLINIC at ¥11,000–¥22,000.
- Q. Is transconjunctival blepharoplasty covered by health insurance in Japan?
- In most cases, this procedure is classified as cosmetic and is not covered by Japan’s national health insurance (shakai hoken or kokumin kenko hoken). Insurance coverage may apply in specific medically indicated situations, but this requires assessment by a physician. Insurance-covered procedures of this nature are handled at Kojimachi Dermatology & Plastic Surgery Clinic (Japanese-language), not at BIOTOPE CLINIC.
- Q. Are results from tear trough filler natural-looking?
- When performed by an experienced injector with appropriate product selection, tear trough filler can produce very natural results. The risk of an unnatural or “overfilled” appearance increases when too much product is used or when filler is placed in a patient whose anatomy is better suited to surgical correction. Clinical reports indicate that under-correction is generally safer than overcorrection in this area, as excess filler under the thin periorbital skin is more visible than in other facial regions.
Have a question about this treatment?
Message us on LINE or WhatsApp — our English-speaking team usually replies the same day.
Summary
Under-eye dark circles have more than one cause, and the most effective treatment depends on accurate identification of that cause. Hyaluronic acid filler is a well-established, reversible option for volume loss and tear trough hollowing, with minimal downtime and results achievable within days.
Transconjunctival blepharoplasty is the appropriate choice when excess fat beneath the lower eyelid is the structural cause of the shadow — offering a long-lasting correction without visible scarring.
Neither approach is universally superior. The choice between injections and surgery should follow a thorough clinical assessment, not a general preference. A qualified plastic surgeon with specific experience in periorbital anatomy is best placed to advise on which option — or combination of options — is appropriate for your individual presentation.
If you have questions about under-eye dark circle treatments, English-speaking consultations are handled at BIOTOPE CLINIC in Shirokanedai (Minato-ku, Tokyo) by Dr. Karibe. Our sister clinic Kojimachi Dermatology & Plastic Surgery Clinic in Ichigaya (Chiyoda-ku) handles Japanese-language insurance dermatology. English enquiries: LINE or WhatsApp.
24/7 Consultation & Booking
Book a Consultation or Treatment
Our English-speaking team responds via LINE or WhatsApp — usually the same day.
References
- Goldberg RA, Edelstein C, Balch K. Fat repositioning in lower eyelid blepharoplasty. Seminars in Ophthalmology. 1998.
- Haddock NT, Saadeh PB, Boutros S, Thorne CH. The tear trough and lid/cheek junction: anatomy and implications for surgical correction. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. 2009.
- De Pasquale A, Russa G, Pulvirenti M, Di Rosa L. Hyaluronic acid filler injections for tear-trough deformity: injection technique and high-frequency ultrasound follow-up evaluation. Aesthetic Plastic Surgery. 2013.
- Morley AM, Malhotra R. Use of hyaluronic acid filler for tear-trough rejuvenation as an alternative to surgery. Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. 2011.
- Rohrich RJ, Ghavami A, Mojallal A. The five-step lower blepharoplasty: blending the eyelid-cheek junction. Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. 2011.
Related Articles
You may also find these articles useful.
- Under Eye Filler Tokyo: Risks, Benefits & Costs
- Under Eye Bags Surgery Tokyo: Transconjunctival Blepharoplasty
SUPERVISED BY
Dr. Jun Karibe
MD
Director
Education & Career
Certifications
Awards
